Learn · Track 5 · Reading the evidence · Lesson 1
Win rate is not the whole story
How often a trade wins says little until you know how much it wins and how much it loses.
win rate counts winners. average P/L counts money. A strategy can win most of the time and still lose money, if its losses are much bigger than its wins.
Two made-up strategies. A wins 90% of the time and makes $100 when it wins, but loses $1,000 when it loses. B wins 40% of the time, makes $300 when it wins and loses $150 when it loses.
Per trade, A averages 0.9 times $100 minus 0.1 times $1,000: a loss of $10. B averages 0.4 times $300 minus 0.6 times $150: a gain of $30. The strategy that wins less often is the one that makes money.
Selling out of the money options tends to win often, because most options expire worth nothing. So the rare big loss is the number to watch. Read the win rate together with the average P/L and the worst losses.
Note. Average P/L = win rate times the average win, minus the loss rate times the average loss.
Check yourself (3 questions)
Strategy A wins 90% of the time. Does it make money?
The win rate alone cannot tell you. In this example it loses $10 a trade.
Which two numbers turn a win rate into an average?
The average win and the average loss.
Why do short options often have a high win rate?
Most options expire worth nothing, so the seller keeps the credit most of the time.